July 13, 2011

Q&A with Janice Diner, social commerce consultant

Posted by: in North America

Whether Janice Diner is speaking to a client or a crowd about social commerce, she is passionate about the possibilities for retailers and their constituents. As the founding partner at Horizon Studios, a social business design consultancy, the Toronto-based Diner works to develop social commerce strategies and brand communities for clients such as Hertz, TD Canada Trust, Sony’s PlayStation and RIM BlackBerry. A former creative director and strategist, Diner spent time at Canadian agencies Sharpe Blackmore (Euro Havas) and Segal Communications (Interpublic).

As we researched our Social Commerce trend report, we talked to Diner about how she sees social commerce evolving and what brands should be doing to keep up in this fast-moving space. Her mantra, the thing she says she tells clients time and again, is that to sell products, they need to be where their customers are—and that isn’t necessarily a brick-and-mortar location. Brands that ignore F-commerce, m-commerce and other forms of social commerce do so at their peril, she warns. Increasingly, the social graph will be the tool that will help brands find customers and customers find brands.

What are we talking about when we talk about social commerce?

I like to focus on the two words: “social,” meaning that you’re in a relationship with the consumer and the brand. And “commerce”: the sale of goods. So it’s the sale of goods that are socially influenced. It’s a subset of e-commerce that involves using social media; it’s online media that supports social interaction and user contributions to assist in the online buying and selling of products and services.

You find social commerce inside Facebook, on e-commerce sites; Twitter is being used for specialty sales all the time; mobile devices—checking in with friends and getting deals. And you’re seeing physical installations that support social interaction to help drive a purchase, like with Macy’s [Magic Fitting Room].

What’s the goal for retailers and brands?

Your goal is to engage in dialogue with your customers and to sell goods. You’re going to take your e-commerce strategy and your marketing strategy, and you’re going to put a social layer.

This is what I tell clients: “We have this new layer. And we’re going to decide which channel makes sense for you, based on your business objective. So if you have an e-commerce engine, then we’re going to implement social tools on your e-commerce engine. We’re going to have a discussion and take a look at the objectives.”

I really think anyone that’s selling on the Web should be experimenting and try a couple of things. We don’t know the answers, we just know that we’re moving this way. And if you’re gaining critical mass inside Facebook, you should be experimenting with selling and servicing your clients on Facebook.

What’s your opinion on the Forrester report that concluded that Facebook commerce is not a necessary strategy for most retailers?

If you’re not exploring commerce opportunities on Facebook, your competition will be. My gut reaction was that it’s an intelligent document, but the conclusions are too early—there’s not enough data to make broad assumptions on success or failure yet

One roadblock might be a privacy issue. How much of my personal information do I have to reveal in order to enter a Facebook store?

When a user moves from their Facebook page to inside a Facebook store, you agree to share your information. But you are agreeing to share the information within the application, meaning that the information lives inside the application only and can’t be merged with an outside database—say, a retailer’s e-commerce site. Facebook prohibits app makers from transferring data about users to outside advertising and data companies.

But why bother—what’s the advantage to retailers and shoppers of using a Facebook store versus a regular e-commerce site?

The argument is that there are 600 million people who have Facebook pages, half of whom show up every day and spend 400 and something minutes a month on Facebook. So they are there, spending time. And then if you add social into it—where you are telling people what you think about a product, what you bought—that’s something you don’t always get on an e-commerce site.

Do you think Facebook stores will replace brands’ e-commerce sites?

We’re talking about augmenting. There’s no business case for Facebook replacing brands’ websites, at least not now.

How does social commerce manifest itself offline?

I love Macy’s Magic [Fitting Room], where you can go into the store, try on something virtually, upload a picture via Facebook and send it to a friend. That’s a great use of social commerce.

So social commerce is really about leveraging that instinct that so many people have to make shopping a social experience?

Right. How many times have you stood in line at a store and seen someone talking on their mobile phone with someone about what they are buying? I was at a Coach store in Florida at Christmastime. The woman in front of me had taken a picture of the purse she was buying and sent it to a friend; I heard her ask, “Do you want me to buy one for you as well?”

The best virtual social experiences mimic real-life social experiences. When I design for a client, I always go back to this rule of thumb: What is the current behavior, and how can we add a social technology layer on to that? How are people engaging socially in our category?” You’re not changing consumer behavior, you’re just adopting it to the virtual.

Like, “Look at this great deal I got”?

Facebook claims post-purchase sharing can increase conversion by two to three times. Whether that’s true or not, I don’t know. But it seems logical to me. That’s the way it works. “I went skiing here, and it was great.” Or, “I’m going to this concert. Anyone want to come with me?”  Facebook is really good in enabling all those things. And they’re all attached to purchasing things.

So that, to me, is what it’s really about. People may be questioning whether social commerce is working, but nothing I’ve done in the last six years was proven before I did it.

Can we look ahead and see how the next six months will play out in social commerce?

Oh, gosh, if I knew it, I’d be building it.

Well, what should retailers and brands be thinking about?

They should be channel agnostic. They should take my goods or technology or whatever they are selling and take it where their audience is. It shouldn’t matter whether it’s online, mobile, at the physical store.

Can you think of a good example?

A really good example is the Starbucks card. It’s utilitarian, it’s got a loyalty aspect, and it has a social layer. I have a Starbucks card. I can put money on that physical card from the website or from the Facebook tab. And I can also have an application on my phone. If one of my Facebook friends has the application on their Facebook, I can buy them a cup of coffee by putting money on their card. So now I’ve got a social sharing layer when I’m transferring payments. When I met a friend in a New York airport, he waved his phone and bought me my coffee on his card. So it’s all one piece of technology, just being distributed across multiple media or channels.

Speaking of virtual payments, Facebook is pushing Facebook Credits, which were originally used for games, into the physical world. Who would take advantage of Facebook Credits?

It was originally a payment system for applications and gamers, and it’s becoming the mandatory payment system inside games. But people are offering other ways to use Credits. Warner Bros., with the movie The Dark Knight, was one of the first ones. This April, Facebook introduced Facebook Deals [Facebook’s version of Groupon]—if you want to purchase the deals, you can purchase them with PayPal, with one of your credit cards, or use your Facebook Credits. Now Walmart, Best Buy and Target all sell Facebook Credit gift cards. Now I can buy real goods. And it’s being supported by people’s newsfeed; it’s being supported by the 600-million-pound gorilla.

Could it end up being its own currency?

What’s to stop it from being its own currency? They are slowly adding features to the credit system, like transferring credits to your friend. That’s transferring payments in real-world terms. Right now, it’s just transferring credits; what’s to say tomorrow it’s not transferring money for real goods? It’s starting to sound like PayPal to me.

What’s the bottom line for brands or retailers—that you’ve got nothing to lose by implementing a social commerce strategy?

You can’t ignore where your customers are; you can’t assume they will just show up in your store. You have to market to them. How can you ignore check-ins? How can you ignore any of these things? You can’t. You have to start experimenting with it. And you have to see what works for you. Probably not everything is going to work. But what are you waiting for—your competition to do it successfully? You don’t have to do everything. But be first. I spend my days looking for clients that are ready.

I think it’s the most amazing time in the world to be in business. We’re in the midst of a revolution; it’s hugely disruptive, but there are incredible opportunities. Every business and every industry needs to be rethought in a social way. As long as you’re rethinking and you’re examining what the potential is for your business, and then you’re trying a little bit of it, you’re fine. You’re moving along. But to do nothing is ridiculous.

2 Responses to "Q&A with Janice Diner, social commerce consultant"

1 | Andrew P

July 14th, 2011 at 12:35 pm

Avatar

Excellent overview of Social Commerce as a whole, but the focus seems to be on connecting brands to consumers. In my mind, the real advantage to Social Commerce is connecting consumers to consumers, which replicates the offline experience of shopping. Specifically, the top tier Social Q&A products are very intriguing and seem to be garnering rapid adoption by online retailers.

Janet mentioned that “The best virtual social experiences mimic real-life social experiences.” I completely agree. Social Q&A allows shoppers to ask questions to customers who have already purchased the item. That would result in a really familiar, fun and effective customer experience.

2 | Janice Diner

July 15th, 2011 at 7:44 am

Avatar

Good point Andrew, adding social plugins like, share and recommend help make commerce social especially the use of Facebook connect Take a look at http://www.tripadvisor and log in with Facebook Connect. it is a very good example of this in action.

Comment Form

JWT AnxietyIndex

10 Trends for 2012

Blog Authors

Rasika Fernandes - New Delhi
Katie Fitzgerald and Jessica Vaughn - New York
Deanna Zammit - New York
Hajime Kato - Tokyo
Maria Orriols - Barcelona
Thomas McGillick- Sydney
Russell Martin - Cape Town
Susie Uzel - London
Ben Hopkins - London
Vannya Martinez - Mexico City
James Richardson - London
Aparna Jain - Calcutta
Sarah Siegel - New York
Jessica Vaughn - New York
katerina
Christine Miranda - New York
Lois Saldana - New York
Meghan McCormick - Emerging Media
Yael Shpiller - Tel Aviv
Peta Bassett - Bangkok
Ceren Coskun - Istanbul
Lindsey Stafford - New York
Ann Mack and Jessica Vaughn - New York
Davina Wertheimer - Johannesburg
Alex Brousseau - New York
Dylan Viner - New York
Michael Koenka - Amsterdam
Marian Berelowtiz and Patty Orsini - New York
Ahmed Mahjoub - Dubai
Nina Yiamsamatha - Emerging Media
Sean Aaron - Emerging Media
Mollie Hill
Andres Colmenares - Bogota
Soh Chin Ong - Singapore
David Linden - Emerging Media
Sigrid Jakob and Rodrigo Maroni - New York
Marian Berelowitz - New York
Carlos Fernandez - New York
Tal Chen - Tel Aviv
Tobei Arai - Atlanta
Jordan Price - Tokyo
Marian Berelowitz and Christine Miranda - New York
Gonzalo Franseca - Buenos Aires
Will Palley - New York
Alexandra Stieber - Atlanta
Patty Orsini - New Jersey
Nina Hammerling Smith - New York
Aaron Baar - Chicago
Ramon Jimenez - Madrid
Anil Bharadiya - Singapore
Marian Berelowitz and Maria Orriols - New York
Mariko Kataoka - London
Ken Fujioka - Brazil
Katerina Petinos - New York
Sharon Panelo - New York
Marian Berelowitz and Sarah Siegel - New York
Katie Fitzgerald - New York
Adrian Barrow - New York
Nick Ayala - New York
Ann Mack - New York
Andrew Hwang - Emerging Media
christine
Ana Hernandes - Sao Paulo
Pam Garcia – Manila
Marina Bortoluzzi - São Paulo
Lina Maria Aguirre - New York

Things to Watch

  • Non-virtual valentines
    February 15, 2012 | 1:45 pm

    In the digital era, saying “I love you” has become so easy, there’s even a Facebook app to do it for you. But these days people are craving physical tokens rather than virtual ones: The idea of Objectifying Objects is one of our 10 Trends for 2012, and stationery is among our 100 Things to Watch for this year. As we noted last November, various digital services now help people send real-world messages. For Valentine’s Day, eHarmony Australia developed an easy way to create a keepsake. For those who “like” the online dating site’s Facebook page and fill in the relevant details, eHarmony’s “Calligraphy Cupids” will craft a handwritten love letter and deliver it. —Will Palley

    Image credit: facebook.com/eharmonyaustralia

  • Cervecería 100 Montaditos
    February 6, 2012 | 11:45 am

    Dubbed “a Spanish Starbucks for sandwiches” by Bloomberg Businessweek, this 11-year-old chain is now targeting international customers with its cheap menu and environment that encourages lingering with friends. Its numerous “montaditos”—a tapas staple that here takes the form of mini-sandwiches—are just €1 in Spain, while beer is €2. 100 Montaditos ventured outside Spain in 2010, opened in Miami in 2011, and plans more North and South American and European outlets for 2012. Watch for others to jump on the montaditos bandwagon. —Jessica Vaughn

    Image credit: 100montaditos.com

  • Tomorrow’s remote control
    January 31, 2012 | 12:30 pm

    When the remote control was brought to market in the early 1960s, it reshaped the way we watched television, creating legions of “couch surfers.” Fifty years later, several alternatives to the traditional touch-button remote are coming to market, positioned as easier, more intuitive means to control the screen.

    At this year’s CES, two major brands showed TVs that integrate voice recognition. LG debuted a remote with voice recognition for its Smart TV, with users able to search the Web, tweet and post to Facebook, by speaking rather than typing. They can’t change the channel or control the volume, however. Most ambitious is Samsung, which released a range of televisions that integrate voice-, gesture- and facial-recognition technologies. Built-in cameras recognize viewers’ faces, automatically signing them in to their user profiles; users can then control the TV via voice commands or gestures.

    As these developments continue, watch for the next generation of easy-to-operate consumer electronics to come to a store near you. —Will Palley

  • Microwork
    January 30, 2012 | 2:00 pm

    Knowledge-based work and routine tasks will increasingly be sliced, diced and contracted to the lowest online bidder as companies and consumers post micro-jobs like proofreading, translation, coding, doing laundry and much more. Coffee & Power, Amazon’s Mechanical Turk, Freelancer.com and others are creating the next assembly line, splitting up knowledge-based assignments. Companies like TaskRabbit, available in five U.S. cities and aiming to expand to 12 this year, focus mostly or errands. Employers get connected to the cheapest global vendor, while hungry workers willing to put in hours can rack up a modest living. —Deanna Zammit

  • 4G for all
    January 25, 2012 | 12:00 pm

    Fourth-generation wireless communications will reach most parts of the globe by the end of 2012. In the BIC markets, China Mobile has started trials in China; in India, several major telecom providers will launch 4G in the first half of this year; and Sky Brazil launched a 4G-based mobile broadband service in December. Meanwhile, more manufacturers are releasing 4G smartphones, including RIM, which debuted the first 4G Blackberry in August. Apple is expected to dive into 4G with the iPhone 5 sometime this year. —Marina Bortoluzzi

    Image credit: digitpedia

  • Wrist wallets
    January 17, 2012 | 11:15 am

    The latest innovation in contactless payments may be a throwback: microchip-embedded wristwatches that enable small mobile payments. Watch2pay, which has adopted the tagline “Time is money,” uses MasterCard’s PayPass technology and comes with a reloadable, prepaid MasterCard (the watches are made by LAKS). So far it’s available in Poland and the U.K., where it launched in November for £99. A few other markets have introduced similar watches in recent years, including Turkey, where Garanti bank has been offering the “Bonus Trink Watch,” which it describes as a “watch-shaped credit card.” —Will Palley

  • Snail meets email
    January 12, 2012 | 10:45 am

    As the U.S. Post Office makes plans to scale back services, there is at least one startup that sees opportunity in the business of snail mail. Austin, Texas-based Outbox plans to soon start testing a service that would intercept mail at local post offices, scan it and send it to a digital mailbox. The target is busy moms, who can use bits of downtime on the go to peruse their paper mail.

    While a few other companies receive and manage bills online, such as Hearst’s Manilla and two-year-old Zumbox, they bypass the post office altogether, setting up a direct line between customers and companies. Outbox assumes there’s still a place for real, honest-to-goodness mail, even if it comes via a digital screen. We’ve written about people creating analog greetings via digital devices—now, ironically, that snail mail could become digitized once again before it gets to its destination. —Patty Orsini

    Image credit: Carlota Soc

  • Lana Del Rey
    January 10, 2012 | 11:00 am

    After a radical rebrand in mid-2011, 24-year-old singer Lizzy Grant re-emerged with a sultry American-retro look and a new name. A few months later she posted an emotionally charged video for her single “Video Games” on YouTube, then promptly sold out an upcoming show in minutes and won Q magazine’s “Next Big Thing” award. The media is abuzz, despite some online griping about her authenticity. Del Rey recently secured a modeling contract, and her debut album, Born to Die, is due Jan. 31. —Will Palley

    Image credit: facebook.com/lanadelrey

  • Armageddon Marketing
    January 3, 2012 | 10:15 am

    The debunking of the notion that the Mayans predicted the world would end in 2012 isn’t going to get in the way of marketing. Mexico, home to part of the Mayan civilization, and its hospitality operators have been using the doomsday story to draw tourists. Axe has been having fun with the idea for a while, creating a Final Edition body spray. With the likes of Harold Camping predicting end times almost daily, some brands with an edge may look to add a little tongue-in-cheek urgency to their product messaging. —Aaron Baar

  • Direct-to-consumer content
    December 22, 2011 | 3:30 pm

    Earlier this month the comedian Louis C.K. announced he would sell a concert video directly to fans online for $5. The novel idea has been a hit: Grosses have already topped $1 million. Watch for more such moves as new distribution models, technologies and consumer habits translate to bypassing the traditional middleman between content creators and their customers.

    In music, for example, services like VibeDeck and Moontoast for Music (Billboard’s No. 2 Top Music Startup of 2011) allow bands to easily sell to fans on Facebook and elsewhere. And authors are using Amazon’s Kindle Direct, Barnes & Noble’s PubIt! and similar platforms to bypass the traditional publishing model. —Marian Berelowitz

  • RSSArchive for Things to Watch »