November 7, 2012

Q&A, Corey Keyes, sociology professor, Emory University

Posted by: in North America

Our October trend report, “Health & Happiness: Hand in Hand,” examines the idea that happiness is increasingly coming to be seen as a core component of health and wellness. As part of our research, we spoke with Corey Keyes, a sociology professor at Emory University in Atlanta, who believes happiness is not just positive emotions and feeling good but also functioning well. He terms this combination “flourishing” and connects it with better mental and physical health. Keyes’ 2002 article “The Mental Health Continuum” introduced scientifically the concept of flourishing and the diagnosis of positive mental health. He explained some of his key ideas for us and why he believes governments and health care systems should work proactively to promote flourishing.

So does it make sense that “A happier you is a healthier you,” which is a notion that people increasingly seem to be embracing?

The way we’ve been approaching it, happiness is one of the key components of positive mental health. So you can’t separate happiness and health, at least when it comes to mental health.

When it comes to linkages having to do with physical health, the emphasis on emotional happiness is key. There’s a tendency to see [happiness] only one way, and that doesn’t do it justice—that is, as hedonic, as emotional, and only feeling good or seeking pleasure. Gratification and pleasure and all those things are fleeting. Happiness is way more than feeling good, and that’s the point of our work. You see this trend taken up now in positive psychology if you look at the number of articles coming out in the last five years around this different kind of happiness that was championed by Aristotle, which is about seeking to function well, to try to achieve an excellence in the way you live and how you function in life. That was happiness for him. It was about doing, not feeling.

The connections of happiness, both feeling good and functioning well, do have very important things to say about your physical health. It has a lot to do with how long you live as well. The relevance now that we’re moving toward is the realization that if you put your values into the right place, you can actually seek a happiness that’s far more sustainable in terms of how you function in life.

What’s contributing to that shift in how we view sustainable happiness?

There’s a sort of bankruptcy that happens in the same way that you can just pursue things that end up being vacuous. They don’t last. I think you get the sense that people want to hold onto something that’s far more durable in their lives and, as I like to say, tether themselves to something far more meaningful. You see that happening with the Baby Boomer generation, and you see that with the Millennials.

As the Boomers age into the last decades of their lives, they’re prioritizing much more meaning in life. And you see the Millennials saying, “Well, I’m looking out into a world that everyone’s expecting me to outdo my parents, but I don’t see that as possible. The only way I’ll do that is if I sacrifice every hour of sleep and try to get all A’s in college and go to the best schools and then have to pay back $150,000 in school debt and get the big house and the great job and have little time for my family.”

Do you think happiness is more important to people now than it was 5, 10 years ago?

It is in some respects. I get the sense that people prioritize it. Even parents, when you ask them what the top two aspirations for their children are—this is a study of midlife parents sending their kids off to college—both fathers and mothers said the top two things were education and happiness. But I don’t think our ordinary lives, our daily lives, nudge us to prioritize [happiness] in the way we carry out our work and our lives right now. So I see a huge disconnect.

Lots of us are arguing we need to move in the well-being direction because there are good public health reasons, but getting our health care system to even talk about more than just insurance coverage is a monumental undertaking. But it’s one we have to move toward because it’s all about preventing the things we can prevent because we have no fixes. And mental illness is one of those. We published a study two years ago showing that if you promote flourishing—which is a combination of feeling good and functioning well—you can prevent mental illness. So there’s lots of evidence to say that the government and public health needs to prioritize this and enable people to live this in their workplace and their community and their schools, but we’re a long way away from that.

Do you think governments will start to see well-being and happiness as a public health concern?

They are. I’ve worked for the last five years with the Public Health Agency of Canada, and they have what is called the Strategic Innovations Branch. Their first step was promoting positive mental health flourishing in order to prevent mental illness. Statistics Canada just released data from their annual survey, and they found over 70 percent of Canadians are flourishing. Compare that to the Netherlands, where we did a population study, and no more than 35 percent of adults were flourishing. We’ve done a major study of college students here in the U.S., and we can’t find more than half bursting in life.

What Canada did was fund nine projects in every province to the tune of over $2 million, each for five years, to engage in research that took on at-risk populations. So governments are doing this. We in the States are not. Canada is way ahead of everyone, and lots of people are talking about it in Australia, New Zealand, the U.K.

Could you talk a bit more about flourishing and why you use that precise word?

When I was involved with positive psychology in the very beginning, I was the only sociologist. And my interest was to take on some serious population health issues. One of the most serious and unappreciated is mental illness. Depression in and of itself is the single most problematic worldwide condition, and in 20 years it’s projected by the World Health Organization to be the leading cause of burden to every country if we don’t change what we’re doing.

I didn’t want to just go around promoting happiness for the sake of it. So I started doing a lot of reading, and when you look at the way in which people have approached well-being, there’s been two traditions that map beautifully the ancient Greek debates about happiness. The Greeks had two camps. One championed hedonism. That wasn’t a bad word—it was about pursuing pleasure or emotional well-being. The other was Aristotle’s camp, which said, no, it’s not about feeling good first, it’s about achieving excellence in the way you live your life, functioning well.

I devised a scale [to measure depression] that measures 14 signs and symptoms that map onto feeling good, feeling sad, having interest in life, and the rest measure functioning well. And you have to have one from emotional well-being combined with 6 out of the 11 positive functioning every day or almost every day in the past month to be flourishing. “Flourishing” was meant as a placeholder for “mental health,” but you can’t use the words “mental health” because everyone thinks you’re talking about either mental illness or merely the absence. I chose that term precisely to connote that we are talking about mental health as the presence of the combination of two kinds of well-being.

How do you see the role of positive psychology in all this?

I remember being at a meeting and introducing my work in 1999, and the reaction was that they were not comfortable with the way I was mixing up the positive with illness. See, I never wanted to separate the positive mental health to the understanding of mental illness. And, second, it was clear that they wanted to focus on emotions. There’s a lot we need to know and understand about emotions, but if feelings are our only comforts in life, not values and functioning well, I think we present a rather narrow view of humanity.

If you looked at the literature on mortality, all it focused on was how positive emotions protect against mortality. But we would show that there are lots of people who feel really good about life, but if you look at the flourishing criteria, functioning well, they don’t even come close. Even in America, 38 percent feel good about a life in which they’re not functioning well. Those people have twice the rate of mental illness as those who feel good about a life in which they meet the criteria for flourishing and functioning well. We just published a paper on mortality in the American Journal of Public Health showing it’s not positive emotions that are protecting against mortality, it’s the combination of feeling good with functioning well. So we have been trying to push the field, argue with them, to say stop thinking all the benefits are coming from feelings, emotions. There’s a lot of benefit that comes from having purpose in life, a sense of contribution, integration, autonomy, all the things that go into flourishing in terms of functioning.

So you start to see positive psychology move in this direction. We have got to find a way to help people function well in society, because lots of people can adapt emotionally to some of the worst circumstances—it’s great that we can do that, but it doesn’t mean we’re living a good life.

You mentioned you’ve just done some research into happiness and the connection to longevity?

There are 11 signs or symptoms of functioning well [in Keyes’ system]. And we measured this in a big national study of U.S. adults in 1995 and followed up 10 years later. These were adults between 25 and 74. What we saw was that flourishing—that is, the combination of feeling good and functioning well—was a predictor of death over that 10-year period, net or independent of things like AIDS, education, race, gender, smoking, diabetes, heart disease, cancer, obesity and exercising. If you were anything less than flourishing, you were at dramatic risk of premature death at all ages, even at the end of life. Flourishing protects against it, for males and females.

This paper is in the November issue of the American Journal of Public Health, and I think this will finally get the attention of the American public health. We focus on death a lot here, and if you can tie things to death, you know, you’ve legitimized something. All the prior studies had only measured emotional well-being. They were claiming, “Feeling good is all good.” We measured all three kinds [of well-being], and when you put feeling good in the equation with psychological well-being, for instance, all the effects of emotional well-being disappeared. So it was all attributable to functioning well. So people will begin to see that as a challenge, especially those who want to champion only feeling good.

Are you seeing more of a prescriptive approach to happiness?

You see more of that in the positive psychology pop literature. There are a lot of good books that have been written by the serious academics, but they end up talking about what they think the research tells you on how to pursue happiness. Again, most of it focuses only on emotional well-being, so it doesn’t present a really complete picture. You do get these prescriptions because it seems to be what helps move books, oddly enough. We’re a nation of “You can’t tell me what to do,” even though we oddly love these books with these prescriptions. I’ve been traveling a good bit, and it’s amazing, other countries, when they hear their government come out with something that says, “This is the thing we ought to be doing,” they’re far more likely to embrace it than to say, “You can’t tell me I shouldn’t smoke,” or “You can’t tell me I should exercise.”

Happiness is “Meet with five people in one week, have a good friend, find flow,” you know? It just isn’t that simple. That works for some people, and it’s part of a whole smorgasbord of things, but ultimately this prescriptive approach will be good in a stalling sense. When it starts to come from a public health perspective, we will begin to move toward what the book Nudge is all about. We’ll try to create a world of choices and things that encourage. It won’t be simply “You have to do this,” but there’s a good way to create a society that enables us to pursue happiness in a genuine way.

You also advocate for a more proactive approach rather than the current reactive one to public health?

We can’t fix our way out of things like mental illness. We’re better off preventing it in the first place.

I see this being the challenge of every nation that undergoes the developmental process. We live longer, but the causes of disease and death shift to chronic things we can’t necessarily fix our way out of. So we use the old system, which was medical, which was all about fixing and repairing to deal with challenges it’s not prepared to deal with. The point of going through that transition [to a developed nation] is to enable more people to add quality to life, not quantity. If you don’t add quality, you’re not going to prevent the things that are causing all kinds of problems to us right now.

China and India are going to go through this right now. The U.K. is doing slightly better [than the U.S.] because after World War II, they had the opportunity to foist on the people the National Health Service, and people embraced it. They love the system, even though they pick at it all the time. The whole point is changing the incentive to saving, not profiting—saving money by preventing, rather than creating more hospitals and treatments for people who have already fallen off the cliff.

Our system is designed to merely be reactive because it’s a business. But we can save money by promoting the very things we want people to have: good health, well-being. That’s where we need to get. If we don’t, the writing’s on the wall. Depression will be causing more problems for nations than cancer, heart disease, anything else.

3 Responses to "Q&A, Corey Keyes, sociology professor, Emory University"

1 | Sage Rainbow

November 13th, 2012 at 3:08 pm

Avatar

You analysis and insight confirms decades of research that positive emotions do indeed play a significant role in health and disease. I have worked with my patients with this approach for nearly five decades.

Thank you for your good work.

Sage

2 | Sage Rainbow

November 13th, 2012 at 3:09 pm

Avatar

Thank you for your good work.

3 | Janvier Rugira

December 9th, 2012 at 9:36 am

Avatar

Thank you for your excellent work in positive psychology, in my recent study I found a very interesting factor that may need to be explored further; among university students, the level of flourishing seems to be higher among the developing nations compared to the levels of flourishing available in the literatures tat I reviewed .

Comment Form

SIGN UP FOR OUR WEEKLY EMAIL NEWSLETTER:

New Trend Report: Meet the New Family

2014 iPad App

JWT AnxietyIndex

Things to Watch

  • Room-sharing service Breather
    September 16, 2014 | 3:30 pm

    Breather

    Described as the “Zipcar for rooms,” Breather is an app that enables access to “beautiful, practical spaces” that can be rented anywhere from 30 minutes to a whole day. While sharing-economy players like LiquidSpace and PivotDesk offer work and meeting spaces, Breather positions its rooms as homey spots that can serve a range of purposes (though not, the founder assures, seedy ones). Rooms include the basics—a desk, a couch, Wi-Fi—as well as some fun touches like a candy jar. Lockitron technology lets users unlock doors with their mobile phones. Breather is available in New York, Montreal and San Francisco, and recently raised $6.5 million in venture capital, citing plans to “own every major market in America.” —Hallie Steiner

    Image credit: Breather

  • Barco Escape’s immersive screens
    September 11, 2014 | 4:15 pm

    Maze Runner

    Escape is a triple-screen system from Barco that “allows you to truly be in the movies, not just at the movies”—in line with the rise of immersive experiences, one of our 10 Trends for 2014 and Beyond. Audiences at five U.S. locations and one Belgian cinema will get their first taste of the concept with next week’s release of The Maze Runner, about a group of teens trapped in a massive maze, which will feature about five minutes of immersive footage at key moments. ScreenX is among the other multi-screen, multi-projection cinema experiences we’ve highlighted. —Aaron Baar

    Image credit: Maze Runner

  • “Smart” personal safety
    September 2, 2014 | 6:01 pm

    Defender

    Earlier this year we wrote about the Guardian Angel, a pendant that alerts emergency contacts whenever wearers feel unsafe, created by JWT Singapore. Smart technology is addressing personal safety in other ways too. The Defender is a smart pepper spray that works in tandem with a mobile app, taking a picture of an attacker while contacting authorities. It’s in the final week of an Indiegogo campaign that has well exceeded its goal. Similarly, First Sign has crowdfunded a smart hairclip that detects physical assault, records the evidence and sends for help.

    Meanwhile, college campuses are embracing a more basic form of this tech, encouraging students to download apps like Rave Guardian and Circle of 6, which enable a chosen network to monitor a student’s GPS location during a night out. In a different vein, students at North Carolina State University made headlines last week for their Undercover Nail Polish, which changes color in the presence of “date rape drugs.” —Allison Kruk

    Image credit: The Defender

  • Nestlé’s animal-welfare standards
    August 28, 2014 | 10:00 am

    Nestle

    We wrote about rising concerns over treatment of the animals that people eat back in 2012 as brands including Burger King, McDonald’s and Hellmann’s pledged to institute more humane practices. We also included Humane Food among our Things to Watch for 2013. The trend recently picked up more steam with Nestlé’s announcement of animal welfare standards for its suppliers worldwide, following an investigation by the group Mercy for Animals.

    “The move is one of the broadest-reaching commitments to improving the quality of life for animals in the food system,” notes The New York Times, “and it is likely to have an impact on other companies that either share the same suppliers or compete with Nestlé.” Observed the influential blogger Food Babe: “People want to know where their food comes from, and in order to survive the next decade, the food industry will have to change.” —Marian Berelowitz

    Image credit: Nestlé

  • Alternative waters
    August 19, 2014 | 1:59 pm

    Vertical Water

    With the coconut water craze going strong, watch for more variations on H2O thanks to consumer interest in more natural alternatives to soda and openness to novel products. Antioxidant-rich maple water (made from maple sap) is gaining attention, while almond water from the startup Victoria’s Kitchen has secured space at Whole Foods and Target. As the AP reports, there’s also cactus, birch and artichoke water—made from either water extracted from the plant or boiled with the ingredient in question—whose makers tout their vitamin and mineral content, as well as their infection-fighting properties. —Allison Kruk

    Image credit: Vertical Water

  • Smart mannequins
    August 13, 2014 | 5:01 pm

    Iconeme

    One of our Things to Watch in 2014, beacons have been popping up everywhere from airports to restaurants to museums. But the biggest pickup for these devices—low-cost transmitters that use Bluetooth to precisely track consumers’ mobile phones and send targeted content—has been among retailers. Now, British retailers including House of Fraser, Hawes & Curtis and Bentalls are testing mannequins outfitted with VMbeacon technology from the startup Iconeme.

    A “smart mannequin” enables nearby shoppers with a related mobile app to get details about what it’s wearing and how to find the products in the store or buy them online. The big question is whether customers will be motivated to opt in; skeptics say the technology doesn’t yet provide enough real benefit. —Allison Kruk

    Image credit: Iconeme

  • De-teching apps
    August 7, 2014 | 10:55 am

    De-teching—the idea that more people will choose to temporarily log off—was one of our 10 Trends for 2011, and in our 2014 trend Mindful Living, we discussed the idea that digitally immersed consumers will try to use technology more mindfully. Perhaps ironically, several new apps aim to help people do so.

    Moment tracks phone use and alerts users when they reach their self-imposed daily limit. Pause is “designed to help us reconnect with real life”; it encourages people to use Airplane Mode and engage in real-world activities, and attempts to turn this behavior into a game among friends. Finally, Menthal is part of a research project out of Germany that helps users find out, “Are you in control of your smartphone? Or is your smartphone controlling you?” —Marian Berelowitz

  • Intuitive eating
    July 29, 2014 | 5:00 pm

    Veggies

    As spotlighted in our 10 Trends for 2014 report, people are becoming more interested in Mindful Living, including the notion of eating more mindfully. And with consumers showing declining interest in dieting, the idea of “intuitive eating”—paying closer attention to the body’s hunger signals rather than following a strict regimen—has been steadily gaining traction. Recent media mentions include articles in Fitness and New Zealand’s Stuff, and a Refinery 29 writer is blogging about adopting the practice. With a recent analysis of studies finding that intuitive eating can be a successful strategy for people who are overweight or obese, watch for more consumers to embrace this anti-diet philosophy. —Allison Kruk

    Image credit: Theresa Kinsella

  • Chinese mega-cities
    July 24, 2014 | 1:15 pm

    Tianjin

    China, home to the world’s second largest rural population, is expected to add close to 300 million more urbanites by 2030, when Shanghai and Beijing will likely account for two of the world’s Top 5 mega-cities, according to new UN research. “We are observing one of the most significant economic transformations the world has seen: 21st-century China is urbanizing on a scale 100 times that seen in 19th-century Britain and at 10 times the speed,” notes a new McKinsey paper on cities and luxury markets. China’s wealth will be concentrated in these urban areas: Over the next decade, McKinsey expects Beijing, Tianjin, Guangzhou, Chongqing and Shenzhen, in addition to Hong Kong, to join the list of “top luxury cities.” —Marian Berelowitz

    Image credit: Jakob Montrasio

  • Brands + Google Glass
    July 15, 2014 | 6:09 pm

    SPG

    As Google Glass makes its way into the hands of more people (last month it became available in the U.K.), brands are experimenting with the new possibilities that the platform affords. In March, Kenneth Cole became the first to launch a marketing campaign—the “Man Up for Mankind Challenge”—through a Glass app. Users were challenged to perform and document good deeds for the chance to win a prize.

    Starwood’s new Glass app, billed as the first such app from the hospitality sector, lets people voice-search its properties, view photos and amenities, get directions and book rooms. An array of other marketers have turned out apps for early adopters, from Sherman Williams’ ColorSnap Glass (easily create a paint chip that mirrors anything in view) to Fidelity (delivers daily market quotes for Glass wearers). —Tony Oblen

    Image credit: SPG

  • RSSArchive for Things to Watch »