December 19, 2012

Q&A with Steven Dean, organizer of Quantified Self New York

Posted by: in North America

One of our 10 Trends for 2013 is the idea that smartphones will become de facto fingerprints, containing our identity all in one place. One aspect of that is the rising role of smartphones in gathering and analyzing data on health and well-being. To learn more about this, we spoke to Steven Dean, organizer of Quantified Self, a Meetup group for people interested in gaining knowledge about themselves through self-tracking. Dean, who has a broad entrepreneurial, design and product development background, is a partner at Prehype, a product innovation studio that incubates new digital companies on behalf of corporations and VCs. We discussed self-monitoring “appcessories,” data overload and the future of health care diagnostics.

One term associated with the Mobile Fingerprint is the notion of the “quantified self.” What’s driving people to use their smartphones and other sensor-laden devices to track elements of their health?

Behind the things we see and do in “quantified self” and what we categorize and label as “quantified self” has been going on for a very long time. So I caution people to recognize that we now have a label for this, and so while it feels like there’s a growing interest in it, we also have to recognize that self-tracking, self-monitoring and self-experimentation have been going on for thousands of years. At its core, “quantified self” is Weight Watchers.

So that’s an important caveat to recognize that this is just a label and a description that we’ve used as we’ve begun looking at another kind of shift that’s been occurring in this nebulous realm of self-monitoring, self-recording, self-tracking, self-experimentation—trying to basically improve ourselves, with health or productivity or other aspects of our lives.

I think the first impetus behind [this trend] was the fact that the sensor that we call an accelerometer dropped significantly in price, well below $1. Most of that was driven by the fact that the auto industry had decided quite a while ago to use accelerometers to trigger airbags. And when they decided that, the price of accelerometers fell to the floor. Then there are smart entrepreneurs who worked at this technology, found that it was cheap and said, “How can we do something?” We have accelerometers in our phone, as well. We’re all basically walking around with accelerometers.

I also believe that design has begun to arrive in the world of health monitoring or wellness monitoring, and that was not there until very recently. I think Nike+ led the force there. My belief is that once you really start to bring good design into the development of those kinds of monitoring devices, then consumer interest increases. It’s just natural.

As important, I think just the notion of tracking ourselves has really increased because of the Internet, that we have created a culture of sharing data, sharing pictures, sharing status updates. Just the fact that we are communicating and sharing with others and sharing all kinds of digital snippets has created a culture of “I’m doing something: Let me tell you, let me record it, and then let me tell someone about it.”

Then, as you’ve already identified, we are all walking around with super powerful personal computers in our pocket that we call phones, and that has transformed us. That has made it easy to track [myself] in the context in which I do something. Before smartphones, there were many of us, including myself, building self-tracking applications in websites. But you’re asking people who don’t live their lives in a browser to take the time to sit down and record, in a Web form, how many glasses of water you drank over the last five days. How many fruits and vegetables you ate yesterday, how many blank, how many blank. That was problematic in many ways because people didn’t live their lives that way.

That began to shift because the phone is this always-connected, data-in-the-cloud kind of interface. They’re either posting a status update, they’re taking a picture, they’re tracking their points at Weight Watchers, they’re sending a text message, they’re responding to a text message, they’re responding to a notification in an app. So it’s just constant dialog between men and the system, and that’s a dialog about behavior or actions or events; things that I do.

What role does the development of smartphone-friendly, sensor-laden “appcessories” like Up by Jawbone and Nike+ FuelBand play in the evolution of self-tracking?

The motivating force behind that is that a data-capture device alone is not really very helpful to anyone who’s interested in shifting behavior, changing behavior, continuing to motivate themselves—whatever it is that their goal is. So many of those sensor devices were needing desperately what I call a service component that provides the feedback mechanism that basically shows you what you’re doing, because most consumers are not interested in data.

[Various companies] came out of the gate with these great data-capture devices, but [version] 1.0 was really lacking around the service component that you wrap around the sensor device. And that service component is “OK, well what do I do? I’ve got the data, now how do you want me to change my behavior? What is it that you want me to do next? Where am I in terms of my progress? What is my goal? And if I’m making progress toward my goal, how am I going to find this out?”

Everyone’s walking around with a very small screen, and [when] you tether that to your sensors, you’ve got this really interesting dialog happening between sensor and phone, and phone and user. So that helps improve the entire ecosystem of the service model. You’ve got something in the form of a phone that provides the feedback on the data that the sensors capture. It’s telling you what kind of progress you’re making towards your goal, or if you’re getting off-track, that screen can tell you what you need to do next.

What will be the cultural or behavioral shift as more people adopt self-tracking technology?

What we’re seeing in quantified-self, for the most part, is consumer-wellness devices and products that have to do with just collecting data about nutrition and diet, whether I’m expending energy or eating energy. It’s a system that is helping me measure and monitor something my brain cannot do. I can’t keep track of how many steps I walk on my own while I’m walking. It’s nearly impossible.

We are essentially increasing the resolution of the sensing that we’re doing around a particular behavior, and the frequency and the range. So if I said to you, “How many fruits and vegetables did you eat on average in the last week?” your memory recall is probably going to be pretty bad. So as we measure a body and your behaviors through these kinds of sensor technologies, more and more, we’re going to get a more accurate reading of your true behaviors, of the things you actually did.

Can you give an example of this?

The example I like to give is a project I worked on last year for asthma patients. [The company] has a sensor that is attached to an asthma inhaler. And every time a patient takes a dose from their inhaler when they have an asthma attack, the sensor records the time stamp of that attack and then makes a connection to the smartphone to leverage and to borrow the GPS functionality in the smartphone to grab the location of that attack.

Before that technology, an asthmatic had literally no real idea of how often they had asthma attacks. And for years, when a doctor would ask an asthma patient how many times they’d had an asthma attack or how many times they used their asthma inhaler in the last 30 days, 80 percent of patients believed their asthma was under control. The facts were really that only 20 percent were under control. It was such a large gap between what people believed they were doing and what they were actually doing in terms of how many asthma attacks they had or how many times they used their inhaler.

So suddenly, once you start to instrument these kinds of behaviors, you get true factual data. That alone is powerful around just bringing an awareness to the things you’re actually doing. But then you start to attach additional levels of data that increase the resolution or the range or the frequency of the data, and you have a powerful story that may help guide that patient to both understanding their asthma better, understanding their condition better, whatever it might be, and then ultimately make some kind of change in their behavior. So if I recognize that 80 percent of my asthma attacks are happening at the workplace, then something’s up at work. There may be some kind of irritant or pollutant in the air that’s causing my attacks.

More and more of your instrumenting and increasing the variety of the sensing of ourselves and our environment and our world is just going to continue to explode and I think it’s going to be transformative around getting more accurate data about things we have questions about.

We’ve seen devices that track activity, sleep and various vital signs like blood pressure. What is the next frontier for self-tracking?

I’m really excited about all the stuff that’s happening inside of our bodies that we can’t see and that we can’t sense with external sensors. Proteus Digital Health already has the first swallowable, ingestible sensor. There will just continue to be more and more [developments].

When you start to combine sensor technology with nanotechnology with synthetic biology, [you gain] the ability to basically sense an organ that might be in distress or failing, or even like postmyocardial infarction. Ingestible and swallowable sensors, even [the ability] to plant the sensor in that body, it’s a fascinating world that I think is going to continue to expand.

You see the instruments on the physical body, but I also think there’s a bigger opportunity for instrumenting the context in which we live and having that communicate back to the sensors on our body or in our bones. Because we don’t live in isolation; we don’t do things in isolation with just our bodies and ourselves. We do it in the world. When you have multiple people with coordinated sensors in the world, and their sensors are kind of talking back to one another … it is not just about the self, it’s also about others. It’s about myself and others, my environment and my city.

One of the things that was really interesting about the [asthma-related] work we did is that we added a sensor data for the individual asthma patient around how many times they’re using their inhaler. But then we also have the collective data about where asthma outbreaks were occurring within a community. Then you had layered on top of that weather data, pollen data. And you can see the different layers that can come in, information layers. The challenge for brands is how to use and coordinate all those layers and data that then tell a story that’s meaningful back to the consumer.

As we layer sensors throughout our worlds, do you think there’s a risk of excess information? Do you think we can know or sense too much?

Absolutely. We’re already in that state. I am already overloaded with information. There’s plenty of anxiety already, and adding more and more [data] is going to create more and more [anxiety].

What are the opportunities for brands looking to help consumers deal with this information?

There’s an opportunity for brands and for entrepreneurs and for designers to be very, very purposeful about a new system that moves us away from that information overload. How do we as a brand acknowledge [consumer anxiety] and design systems and services to address that, so we continue to take advantage of this wonderful technology to learn more and more about ourselves and our environment and our world—but in such a way that it’s thoughtful and purposeful, and meaningful without a spooky overlay of sensor upon sensor upon sensor, data upon data. With all new technologies, those are questions and discussions and debates and discourse that we should have.

Many of us, particularly those of us in health, we see the real opportunity here to do the kinds of things we’ve just never been able to do in health. I think it’s going to be transformative to the health care system. I’ve told many people that if you’re in the business of diagnostic health, your days are numbered, because sensors and devices and apps can do all of this. [We] don’t need a diagnostician to diagnose things.

I have hearing loss, so I went to an audiologist a couple of years ago, and I had to do a very elaborate exam that took two or three hours. There’s an app I downloaded that showed me exactly the same result I got from this audiologist, and I did this in minutes. To me, the writing is right there, on the wall. Diagnostics is going to go the way of sensors.

If I were to predict the company or the brand that’s going to build these kinds of things, it’s someone who will build a service that allows people to fully personalize their dashboard based on the apps features and functions and sensors that they’re currently using, and kind of build it in an ad hoc way. There’s a huge opportunity for someone to come in and completely redesign annual health physicals through just technology, through the phone and sensors.

[It’s easier] starting with a niche condition, and then you can naturally grow by attaching additional sensors or instruments to that.

As brands layer on compatibility with social networks like Facebook and Twitter, how do you think people will feel about sharing their data not only with brands but with each other?

When it comes to health data, and I define that broadly from weight to my audiology score, I think places like Facebook are not the right venues for sharing that. We don’t see very much of it. We don’t even see very much of it on Twitter. But I do think wellness data is something you share if it’s a closed group that’s supporting one another around that particular change or condition. You’re much more apt to share in that kind of environment. Everyone is different around this stuff, and some of the stuff is very personal and very private, and some people get huge benefit and value from sharing it with others like them.

1 Response to "Q&A with Steven Dean, organizer of Quantified Self New York"

1 | Davis Masten

December 23rd, 2012 at 9:35 pm

Avatar

Hi Steven, Thanks for writing such a good overview of QS. I collaborate with Gary Wolf at QS Labs. I, too, have a hearing problem. What’s the name of the app you use for audiology? I’d love to check it out. Thanks! Davis

Comment Form

Updates

Sign up for Email Updates

JWT AnxietyIndex

10 Trends for 2013

Blog Authors

Anil Bharadiya - Singapore
Russell Martin - Cape Town
Meghan McCormick - Emerging Media
Gonzalo Franseca - Buenos Aires
Mollie Hill
Alex Morrison - New York
Deborah Frenkel - Melbourne
Alex Brousseau - New York
Mariko Kataoka - London
Nick Ayala - New York
Thomas McGillick- Sydney
Aparna Jain - Calcutta
Sharon Panelo - New York
Nina Yiamsamatha - Emerging Media
Marian Berelowitz and Sarah Siegel - New York
christine
Alec Foege - New York
Ann Mack and Jessica Vaughn - New York
Andrew Knight and Jessica Vaughn - New York
Geri Kan - Singapore
Jessica Vaughn - New York
James Richardson - London
Ahmed Mahjoub - Dubai
Marian Berelowtiz and Patty Orsini - New York
Davina Wertheimer - Johannesburg
Michael Koenka - Amsterdam
Tobei Arai - Atlanta
Mennah Ibrahim - Beirut
Ana Hernandes - Sao Paulo
Juliana Cubillos and Jessica Vaughn - Bogota and New York
Nina Hammerling Smith - New York
Pam Garcia – Manila
Hajime Kato - Tokyo
Adrian Barrow - New York
Lindsey Stafford - New York
Lina Maria Aguirre - New York
Ann Mack - New York
Marian Berelowitz - New York
Will Palley - New York
Christine Miranda - New York
Sarah Siegel - New York
Ceren Coskun - Istanbul
Jordan Price - Tokyo
Katie Fitzgerald - New York
Andres Colmenares - Bogota
Katie Fitzgerald and Jessica Vaughn - New York
Tal Chen - Tel Aviv
Harsha Prag - Johannesburg
David Linden - Emerging Media
katerina
Susie Uzel - London
Jessica Vaughn and Sarah Siegel - New York
Ben Hopkins - London
Katerina Petinos - New York
Deanna Zammit - New York
Ramon Jimenez - Madrid
Colette Henry - Dublin
Aaron Baar - Chicago
Rasika Fernandes - New Delhi
Marina Bortoluzzi - São Paulo
Yael Shpiller - Tel Aviv
Carlos Fernandez - New York
Sean Aaron - Emerging Media
Sigrid Jakob and Rodrigo Maroni - New York
Lois Saldana - New York
Marian Berelowitz and Christine Miranda - New York
Alexandra Stieber - Atlanta
Dylan Viner - New York
Alex Pallete and Ramon Jimenez - Madrid
Patty Orsini - New Jersey
Marian Berelowitz and Will Palley - New York
Andrew Hwang - Emerging Media
Peta Bassett - Bangkok
Marian Berelowitz and Maria Orriols - New York
Maria Orriols - Barcelona
Soh Chin Ong - Singapore
Ken Fujioka - Brazil
Vannya Martinez - Mexico City
Kimberly Douglas - London

Things to Watch

  • Catering to kid foodies
    May 15, 2013 | 2:30 pm

    Last year we wrote about kid foodies: how kids are becoming more interested in what they eat and the art of cooking. A few new manifestations of this have popped up. In the U.S. last week, Fox announced it would launch Junior MasterChef, a spinoff of MasterChef, to be hosted by Gordon Ramsay. The kids version of this competition has already debuted in markets including the U.K., Israel and Thailand. And in the U.K., Tesco has linked with cooking site Great British Chefs on a free iPhone and iPad app featuring recipes “specially conceived to be cooked with children”; a section of the site features these easy recipes as well. Meanwhile, the James Beard Foundation has named ChopChop its top food publication of the year: The 3-year-old nonprofit magazine aims to motivate American kids to eat better by providing fun recipes for families to make together. —Marian Berelowitz

  • Tokidoki collaborations
    May 7, 2013 | 2:36 pm

    What do Karl Lagerfeld, Hello Kitty and Iron Man have in common? They’ve all been Tokidokied. The Italian brand’s cute-yet-edgy Japanese-inspired cartoon characters have amassed a cult following since 2005. Tokidoki (“sometimes” in Japanese) has partnered with product categories from makeup (Sephora and Smashbox) to bags (LeSportsac) to headphones (Sol Republic), and its momentum has yet to slow. The new Lagerfeld concept store in Paris is selling a limited-edition vinyl “Karl” Tokidoki figurine. In Singapore, 7-Eleven customers get a stamp for every SG$4 they spend in-store, and 18 stamps earns a Tokidoki Hello Kitty figurine—a promotion that’s creating lots of buzz among young lifestyle bloggers and collectors who want the series of 10.

    Campaign Asia attributes the success of Tokidoki, the creation of Italian designer Simone Legno, to word-of-mouth, social media and a cost-effective marketing strategy that leverages its partners’ brand values, communication channels and customer bases. —Geri Kan

    Image credit: Tokidoki

  • Pets Unstressing Passengers
    April 29, 2013 | 5:30 pm

    One of the more cuddly manifestations of our trend The Super Stress Era—the idea that governments, employers and brands will be working harder to address stress as it mounts around the world—is a new program at Los Angeles International Airport called Pets Unstressing Passengers (yes, that’s PUP for short). In our 10 Trends for 2013 report, we cite “cat cafés” in Tokyo and Shanghai, designed to help soothe patrons. Now dogs are getting their turn: At LAX, volunteers with trained pooches ready to be petted will roam departure gates to help defuse travelers’ tension. The program is modeled on similar, smaller-scale efforts at San Jose and Miami airports.  —Marian Berelowitz

  • McDonald’s’ Hong Kong ‘Happy Bus’
    April 23, 2013 | 3:00 pm

    Among our 10 Trends for 2013 is The Super Stress Era: the idea that governments, employers and brands will ramp up efforts to address stress as it mounts around the world. In Hong Kong, a McDonald’s Value Meals campaign is reminding stressed-out residents that “It doesn’t take much to be happy.” The city is “a stressful environment in which many people forget that happiness doesn’t have to be expensive or complicated,” says a McDonald’s marketing director in a press release. Indeed, in a 2012 Regus survey, 55 percent of Hong Kong respondents said their stress levels had risen in the past year.

    In addition to airing commercials that show silly, lighthearted moments of fun, McDonald’s kitted out a double-decker “Happy Bus,” which plies the busy Cross Harbour Tunnel route, with a motion sensor that makes laughing sounds when passengers swipe their Octopus cards and seat backs featuring optical illusions—replacing passengers’ hairstyles with Ronald McDonald’s. And distorting mirrors at bus stops feature reminders to smile. —Geri Kan

  • Multimedia messaging
    April 16, 2013 | 11:30 am

    As discussed in our latest report, “13 Mobile Trends for 2013 and Beyond,” people are using mobile devices to communicate in multiple new ways that are more visual, richer, faster, easier, more automated or simply more fun. One way they’re doing so: with messaging apps like Line, Viber and KakaoTalk, which have become “an indispensable form of communication for hundreds of millions of people worldwide,” as The Wall Street Journal notes. Depending on the service, users can embed content like songs, video, images and doodles; communicate via emoticons and virtual stickers; share location; and play games while chatting. Stickers (some free, some premium) are a world in themselves, from dancing pizza slices to proprietary characters. The app Rednote lets users add music to texts, choosing songs based on the mood they want to convey.

    The numbers are impressive: MessageMe garnered more than a million users within a week of its launch last month. Line claims 120 million downloads. To compete with these over-the-top apps, mobile operators are launching their own services, like Libon from Orange and Bobsled from T-Mobile USA. —Marian Berelowitz

    Image credit: Rednote

  • Virgin Active, ‘Live Happily Ever Active’
    April 9, 2013 | 1:00 pm

    Virgin Active began the year asking South Africans, “Can being more active make you happier?” The company, which operates 100-plus health clubs across the country, is going beyond the gym, providing digital solutions to encourage consumers to be more active and so “Live Happily Ever Active”—in line with one of our 10 Trends for 2013, Health and Happiness: Hand in Hand. While the link between body and mind isn’t a new concept, the idea that health impacts happiness and vice versa is becoming more ingrained for consumers and a theme for marketers.

    Virgin Active’s online tool devises training routines and provides advice and resources to help people achieve their goals. Members are encouraged to make active choices with the range of exercise classes on offer. The brand is also asking South Africans to share “Happily Ever Active” stories across social media sites to demonstrate that being healthy is a sure route to being happy. — Harsha Prag

    Image credit: Virgin Active

  • Mobile dating app Tinder
    April 4, 2013 | 11:47 am

    Launched last fall, this mobile dating app is hitting it big with its predominantly Millennial users—clocking in with 20,000 daily downloads, more than 2 billion rated profiles, 20 million matches, and 65 percent of users logging in daily and 80 percent weekly. What primarily distinguishes Tinder is the way it enables snap judgments based on member photos, a process “designed to be familiar and emulate the way we interact in real life,” as the website puts it. Relying on Facebook integration, Tinder lets users scroll through photos of people within their set parameters who are most likely to prove a match, tapping a green heart if interested, a red X if not. Tinder then connects users when interest is mutual, eliminating fears of rejection and unwanted attention.

    The app shoots away any pretense that it’s not all about looks for this cohort and speaks to our culture of impatience (and the resulting emphasis on images over words) and hyper-efficiency. —Nick Ayala

    Image credit: Tinder

  • XM Gravity’s Happiness App
    March 27, 2013 | 4:45 pm

    As we noted in our 10 Trends for 2013, more people are coming to recognize the link between health and happiness and taking proactive steps to improve both at once. Indonesia-based digital agency XM Gravity, a JWT company, recently created a mobile app designed to keep employees feeling happy, connected and cared for. The app’s “Mood” function asks users to choose one of nine emotions (excited, mad, relaxed, etc.); executives or HR personnel will seek out people who consistently specify negative moods in an effort to fix the situation. A “News” section features fun announcements (free ice cream, movie screenings, company trips).

    “The Happiness App serves as a sort of heart check up on everyone in the company,” explained CEO Kevin Mintaraga. Since a happier person is a healthier person, he said, “in the end, they are the ones who would give their best at work.” —Will Palley

  • Transient hotels
    March 21, 2013 | 4:15 pm

    These days, it’s hotels that are on the move, not the guests. Transient, or pop-up, hotels offer affordable rooms in prime spots or posh lodging near seasonal events such as music festivals. Sleeping Around, a Belgian company, transforms 20-foot shipping containers into luxury rooms and transports them to cities around the continent. The Pop-Up Hotel, a British firm, will supply luxury safari tents at June’s Glastonbury Music Festival, as well as a full restaurant and “exclusive luxury toilets,” no doubt a valuable festival perk. Podpads will also offer rooms at Glastonbury, but theirs look like small plywood cottages. Another business using shipping containers as rooms, Snoozebox, operated at the London Olympics, achieving 85 percent occupancy, and became a surprise financial success. This week The New York Times spotlights a few additional options.

    With travelers increasingly interested in one-of-a-kind adventures, these hotels help provide an experience that few friends will be able to replicate. —Alec Foege

    Image credit: The Pop-Up Hotel

  • Dim Sum Warriors
    March 12, 2013 | 2:15 pm

    Apps and digital technologies are helping to make education ever more creative and entertaining. Take Dim Sum Warriors, a clever interactive comic series that aims to help readers learn Mandarin Chinese (or, conversely, English) in a way that is “innovative, effective and fun.” Students using an iPad can follow the adventures of Prince Roast Pork Bun, son of Empress Custard Bun, in Chinese script or English—touching a speech balloon summons a translation and audio rendition (simply tapping results in just the audio), as demonstrated here. (The comic is also available in print or in a Kindle version, in English.) The series is produced by a Flushing, N.Y.-based couple who love food, martial arts, cartoons and education; the wife is an education professor, the husband a cartoonist. —Geri Kan

    Image credit: Dim Sum Warriors

  • RSSArchive for Things to Watch »